Skip to content

A Libertarian party only works if members can vote their conscience, and if the rest of us respect that vote.

That sounds obvious. In practice, it gets harder when a vote stops being a simple judgment call and starts carrying social weight. People worry about how a vote will be received more than their own opinion. Some take disagreement personally. Others change a vote, or skip one, just to stay out of the conflict.

That is worth talking about calmly.

A vote is a judgment, not an attack. A member who votes differently is still a fellow member to be respected. Too often I hear a differing vote by a fellow member is treated as a personal wound instead of a difference of judgment. That reaction may be understandable, but it does not lend itself to an environment where individuals can freely make choices on their own .

Every member has the right to vote their conscience, even when the majority disagrees, even when prominent voices disagree, even when someone is disappointed by the result, and with out the backlash being ousted as not being libertarian. But this does not always.

A member once felt socially pressured to conform to group expectations and present photographic proof of their vote. They photographed and shared their vote to receive the affirmation of the group, but then submitted their real vote instead. No member should feel the need to do this!

On another occasion I was presented with an email where a member cast shade towards other members who voted in a way they took personally. I would like to say it was just one email or social post of that type that had crossed my computer screen, but it wasn’t. I read many times the same recurring theme, just worded differently, with the same tone.

I personally no longer say how I vote on candidates. Those votes are personal judgments, they are no one else’s business, and the backlash I have received and saw others receive from previous votes, IMO, not only crossed a line but made me feel like I didn’t have the freedom to choose on my own with out social repercussions. It felt bullying. And just because I was silent, it didn’t stop some from assuming the worst. The choice to not state my vote for a candidate was merely a lesser of two evils.

As members and an organization, we need to do better.

The Final Say

Respecting a vote does not mean agreeing with it. On candidate votes, it means arguing the candidate or the endorsement — not the member’s identity. You can say you do not agree with a choice and still treat the voter as a member in good standing.

A healthy liberty-based party should be a place where:

The principles cover every vote: candidates, officers, bylaws, and motions. Some votes are open by design. A show of hands is public in the room. Other votes can be kept private. Either way, the duty is the same: respect the voter. How a vote is taken does not change that.

On the next vote, speak to the issue, not the voter. When the vote is over its over and the vote is respected as well as the members who placed their votes. That does not mean silence when something does not go the way one expects. It means the disagreement ends with the vote, not with the member.

You are free to vote as you wish. The rest of us should respect that. That freedom is worth protecting for all of us.


Disclaimer: Member articles are published to encourage debate and discussion within the party. The views and opinions in each piece belong to the author and do not always reflect any platform plank or official LP stance. We encourage people to challenge the status quo — including our own.

One Response

  1. I understand completely what this article is saying. One thing that all libertarians believe is that my vote is my own. It doesn’t belong to my party. It’s my vote. Most members of the current state board, on which I serve, do not care what members think, unless it’s what they think.

    That is not Libertarian.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *